Crime and justice is one of the most powerful topics you can bring into an ESL classroom. It sparks genuine opinions, builds critical thinking, and gives students real-world language they will actually use.
Whether your learners are beginners talking about neighborhood safety or advanced students debating the ethics of capital punishment, the right question unlocks authentic, flowing conversation.
This collection of 400+ ESL conversation questions on crime and justice is organized by CEFR level — from A1 all the way to C2 — so you can pick exactly the right questions for your class without any preparation stress.
Scroll down to find your level, grab the vocabulary list at the end, and check the teacher tips for ideas on how to use these questions effectively.
Table of Contents
A1–A2 Beginner Questions on Crime and Justice (60 Questions)
These questions use simple vocabulary and familiar situations. They focus on personal safety, basic rules, and everyday observations — ideal for getting beginners talking without intimidation.
Safety and neighbourhood
- Do you feel safe in your neighbourhood?
- Is your town or city safe?
- Do you lock your door at night?
- Have you ever seen a police officer near your home?
- Do you know your neighbours? Are they friendly?
- Is there a lot of traffic in your neighbourhood?
- Are there security cameras near your home?
- Do you feel safe walking alone at night?
- Have you ever called the police?
- What do you do if you lose something valuable?
Rules and right or wrong
- What rules are important in your home?
- What school rules did you have as a child?
- Is it wrong to tell a small lie? Why or why not?
- Have you ever broken a rule? What happened?
- What happens when someone breaks a rule in your country?
- Do you think rules are important? Why?
- What is one rule you think everyone should follow?
- Is it ever okay to break a rule?
- Have you ever seen someone break a rule in public?
- What do you do when you see someone doing something wrong?
Police and emergency services
- Have you ever spoken to a police officer?
- What do police officers do in your country?
- Do you trust the police? Why or why not?
- What number do you call in an emergency in your country?
- Have you ever seen an ambulance or fire truck?
- What would you do if you saw an accident on the street?
- Do police officers in your country carry guns?
- Have you ever visited a police station?
- What do you think is the most dangerous job — police officer, firefighter, or doctor?
- Would you like to be a police officer? Why or why not?
Stealing and property
- Have you ever lost something? How did you feel?
- Have you ever had anything stolen?
- What would you do if you found a wallet on the street?
- Is it okay to take something that does not belong to you?
- What would you do if you saw a child stealing food?
- Have you ever accidentally taken something that was not yours?
- Do you think stealing is always wrong?
- What is the punishment for stealing in your country?
- Have you ever broken something that belonged to someone else? What did you do?
- What would you do if a friend stole something?
Laws and fairness
- What is one law in your country that you think is good?
- What is one law you think is unfair?
- Do you think men and women have the same rights in your country?
- Is it fair for everyone to follow the same rules?
- What happens if someone drives too fast in your country?
- Is it okay to park anywhere you like?
- Do you always wear a seatbelt?
- What is the age limit for buying alcohol in your country?
- Do you think the speed limit on roads is fair?
- What would happen if there were no laws?
Mixed beginner questions
- Do you watch crime shows on TV?
- What is your favourite crime film or TV series?
- Do you think there is a lot of crime in your city?
- Is crime increasing or decreasing in your country?
- What crime do you hear about most often in the news?
- Is graffiti a crime or art?
- Should children learn about crime and safety at school?
- What do you think is the most serious crime?
- Do you think more police would make your city safer?
- What would you do if you witnessed a crime?
B1 Pre-Intermediate Questions on Crime and Justice (80 Questions)
At this level, students can express opinions and give reasons. These questions introduce common crime types, court proceedings, and social perspectives on law and order.
Types of crime
- What is the most common type of crime in your country?
- Do you think vandalism is a serious crime?
- Have you ever been the victim of pickpocketing or theft?
- What do you know about organised crime in your country?
- Is drug use a crime in your country?
- What do you think causes people to commit crimes?
- Do you think poverty is a major cause of crime?
- Is domestic violence taken seriously in your country?
- What crimes do you think young people commit most often?
- Have you ever been involved in or witnessed road rage?
Police and law enforcement
- Do you think the police in your country do a good job?
- Should police officers be armed at all times?
- What training do you think police officers should have?
- Have you ever seen police using force? How did you feel?
- Should police wear body cameras at all times? Why?
- Do you think there is corruption among police in your country?
- How should police handle protests?
- Do you think community policing (police working closely with local people) is a good idea?
- Should police be able to search your phone without a warrant?
- Do you think there should be more female police officers?
Courts and punishment
- Have you ever been inside a courtroom?
- Do you think the court system in your country is fair?
- Should rich people and poor people receive the same punishment for the same crime?
- What do you think is a fair punishment for stealing?
- Do you think community service is an effective punishment?
- Is prison always the best punishment for criminals?
- How long do you think someone should go to prison for robbery?
- Should first-time offenders receive lighter sentences?
- Do you think fines are an effective punishment?
- What do you think is the most effective way to stop repeat offending?
Young people and crime
- At what age should a person be held responsible for their actions?
- Should teenagers who commit serious crimes be treated as adults in court?
- What do you think leads young people to join gangs?
- How can schools help prevent youth crime?
- Does social media encourage criminal behaviour among young people?
- Should parents be held responsible for crimes committed by their children?
- Do you think violent video games contribute to crime?
- What programmes exist in your country to help young offenders?
- Should young offenders go to prison, or are there better options?
- How does poverty affect youth crime rates?
Victims and society
- What support is available for crime victims in your country?
- Do you think the rights of victims are protected in your country?
- Should victims have a say in sentencing?
- How does being a victim of crime change a person?
- Do you think crime reporting in the media is too sensational?
- Does media coverage of crime make people more afraid than they need to be?
- Should the names of convicted criminals be published in the news?
- Do you think crime rates have gone up or down in recent years? Why?
- Does more CCTV make society safer or does it invade privacy?
- What can ordinary citizens do to help reduce crime?
Famous and historical crimes
- Can you name a famous crime or criminal from your country?
- What is the most famous unsolved crime you know of?
- Why do people find true crime stories so fascinating?
- Do you think watching true crime documentaries is healthy?
- Have you ever read a crime novel? Who is your favourite crime author?
- What famous trials have you heard about in history?
- Do you think historical crimes (e.g., by governments) should be punished?
- Should war criminals always be prosecuted, no matter how old they are?
- Can a country move on from a dark past without punishing those responsible?
- Should statues of criminals or oppressors be removed?
Mixed B1 questions
- Is it ever okay to take the law into your own hands?
- What is vigilante justice? Do you think it is ever justified?
- Would you report a friend or family member to the police if they committed a crime?
- Do you think legalising some drugs would reduce crime?
- Should prostitution be legalised to reduce related crime?
- Is jaywalking a serious crime?
- Should it be illegal to smoke in public places?
- What do you think about the law on drunk driving in your country?
- Is it a crime to not help someone who is injured in a public place?
- Do you think the justice system treats all people equally?
Mixed B1 questions (continued)
- Should illegal immigrants who have committed no crime be deported?
- Is graffiti ever art? Should it be decriminalised?
- Do you think governments spy on ordinary citizens? Is that acceptable?
- Should companies that pollute the environment face criminal charges?
- Is tax evasion as serious as theft?
- Do you think penalties for drink driving are strict enough?
- Should a person go to prison for simply possessing a small amount of drugs?
- Are hate crimes different from other crimes? Should they be punished more severely?
- Should animal cruelty be treated as seriously as violence against humans?
- How should cyberbullying be treated by the law?
B1–B2 Intermediate Questions on Crime and Justice (100 Questions)
These questions are ideal for learners who can hold a sustained discussion. They explore social causes of crime, the prison system, rehabilitation, the death penalty, and real-world ethical dilemmas.
Causes of crime
- Is unemployment a major cause of crime? Why?
- How does inequality contribute to crime rates?
- Does poor education lead to higher crime rates?
- Is addiction a disease or a choice? How should the law treat addicts?
- How does mental illness relate to crime?
- Are some people born criminals, or is crime always a product of environment?
- How does family background influence criminal behaviour?
- Does living in a deprived area make someone more likely to commit crime?
- Do you think race or ethnicity affects how a person is treated by the justice system?
- How can governments address the root causes of crime?
Prison and rehabilitation
- What is the purpose of prison — punishment, rehabilitation, or both?
- Are prisons in your country overcrowded?
- What are conditions like in prisons in your country?
- Should prisoners be allowed to vote?
- Should prisoners have access to education and job training?
- Do you think rehabilitation programmes work?
- Should prisoners receive the same healthcare as ordinary citizens?
- What happens to prisoners after they are released?
- How hard is it for ex-convicts to find work?
- Should employers be allowed to reject job applicants with a criminal record?
- What is a halfway house? Do you think they are effective?
- Should there be a limit on how long someone can be in solitary confinement?
- Do you think private prisons are a good idea?
- Should people convicted of non-violent crimes go to prison at all?
- What alternative punishments could replace prison for minor crimes?
The death penalty
- Does your country have the death penalty?
- Do you think the death penalty is ever justified?
- For which crimes, if any, should the death penalty apply?
- Do you think the death penalty deters crime?
- Is it morally acceptable for the state to take a life?
- What do you think about countries that still use the death penalty?
- Has an innocent person ever been executed in your country?
- How does the risk of executing innocent people affect your view on the death penalty?
- Should the death penalty be applied equally, regardless of race, wealth, or background?
- What methods of execution are used in your country or others? Do you think they are humane?
Cybercrime
- Have you or someone you know ever been the victim of cybercrime?
- What is the most common type of cybercrime in your country?
- How should hackers be punished?
- Is online fraud as serious as in-person theft?
- How can you protect yourself from cybercrime?
- Should governments be allowed to hack into private systems to prevent terrorism?
- What do you think about identity theft? How can people prevent it?
- Is pirating music and films a serious crime?
- Should social media companies be held legally responsible for harmful content on their platforms?
- Do you think artificial intelligence will make cybercrime worse?
Drug-related crime
- What drugs are illegal in your country?
- Should cannabis be legalised everywhere?
- Has drug legalisation worked in countries that have tried it?
- Should drug addicts go to prison or receive treatment?
- What is the link between drug trafficking and organised crime?
- How should the government tackle drug trafficking?
- Should people who deal drugs receive harsher sentences than users?
- Is alcohol more dangerous than some illegal drugs?
- Do you think the war on drugs has been successful?
- Should drug users be criminalised or treated as patients?
Corruption
- Is corruption a major problem in your country?
- Have you ever witnessed or experienced corruption first-hand?
- Is it ever acceptable to bribe a public official?
- How does corruption damage a country’s economy?
- What can governments do to reduce corruption?
- Should whistleblowers who expose corruption be protected by law?
- Do you think the press does enough to expose corruption?
- Is corporate corruption punished severely enough?
- What do you think of politicians who take bribes?
- Would you report corruption if you saw it? Why or why not?
Moral dilemmas
- Would you steal food to feed your starving child?
- If you saw your neighbour vandalise a car, would you report them?
- If you found a large amount of cash, what would you do?
- Would you lie to protect a friend who had committed a crime?
- Is it wrong to break the law to protest against an unjust law?
- Should civil disobedience be treated as a crime?
- If you knew a criminal who had turned their life around, would you hire them?
- Is revenge ever justified?
- Could you ever forgive someone who had committed a serious crime against you?
- Should someone be punished for a crime they committed many years ago if they have changed completely?
B2 Upper-Intermediate Questions on Crime and Justice (100 Questions)
These questions push students to discuss systemic issues, media influence, human rights, and complex social debates around crime and the legal system.
Systemic inequality and justice
- Do you think the justice system is equally fair to people of all races?
- Are wealthy people treated differently in the justice system? Give examples.
- Is there such a thing as institutional racism in policing?
- What does it mean for justice to be truly blind?
- Should socioeconomic background be considered during sentencing?
- How does access to good legal representation affect outcomes in court?
- Is the current bail system fair to people who cannot afford to pay?
- Should legal representation be fully funded by the state for all defendants?
- What reforms would you make to the justice system in your country?
- How does gender affect treatment within the justice system?
Media, crime, and public perception
- Does media coverage of crime create moral panic?
- Should the media be restricted from covering ongoing criminal trials?
- Does glorifying criminals in films or music encourage crime?
- Has social media made it easier or harder to solve crimes?
- Should the public be able to comment on active police investigations via social media?
- Do you think true crime podcasts trivialise real suffering?
- Should graphic crime scenes be shown on television news?
- Does media reporting create prejudice against certain groups?
- How has the internet changed the way crimes are investigated and solved?
- Should people be able to livestream police arrests on social media?
Human trafficking and modern slavery
- What is human trafficking? Is it a major problem in your country?
- Who are the most vulnerable groups to human trafficking?
- What can governments do to combat human trafficking?
- Should victims of trafficking be treated as criminals or as victims?
- Is there a link between human trafficking and legal industries such as agriculture or fashion?
- What is the role of international cooperation in fighting human trafficking?
- Should companies be legally required to prove their supply chains are free from slavery?
- How can ordinary people help in the fight against human trafficking?
- Should sex work be fully legalised to reduce exploitation?
- What should be done to support survivors of trafficking?
Drug policy and reform
- What has been the impact of drug legalisation in countries like Portugal or the Netherlands?
- Should drug possession for personal use be decriminalised everywhere?
- Does a focus on criminalising drug use make the drug problem worse?
- Should governments invest more in drug education instead of enforcement?
- How effective are drug courts compared to regular criminal courts?
- Should recovering addicts receive reduced sentences?
- Is prescription drug addiction treated differently from illegal drug addiction? Should it be?
- What are the economic arguments for and against legalising cannabis?
- How has legalisation affected crime rates in states in the US where cannabis is legal?
- Should all drugs be regulated and sold by the government?
Terrorism and national security
- How should countries deal with domestic terrorism?
- Is it acceptable to sacrifice civil liberties for the sake of national security?
- Should suspected terrorists be tried in civilian courts or military tribunals?
- Does torture ever have a place in extracting information from terrorists?
- Should people who have fought for terrorist organisations abroad be allowed to return home?
- How should social media platforms deal with terrorist recruitment?
- Is it ever possible to understand why someone becomes a terrorist?
- What is the difference between a terrorist and a freedom fighter?
- Should governments negotiate with terrorists?
- How can communities help prevent radicalisation?
Technology, surveillance, and privacy
- Should facial recognition technology be used by police?
- Does mass surveillance make society safer or does it destroy civil liberties?
- Do you think your government monitors your online activity?
- Should law enforcement be allowed to use AI to predict crimes before they happen?
- Is it ethical to use DNA databases to solve cold cases?
- How reliable is CCTV evidence in court?
- Should police have access to private data held by tech companies?
- What are the risks of AI-generated false evidence in criminal trials?
- Should hacking be permitted in order to catch criminals?
- How does the dark web complicate law enforcement efforts?
White-collar crime
- Is white-collar crime punished as severely as street crime?
- Does financial fraud cause more damage to society than violent crime?
- Should corporate executives go to prison for environmental crimes?
- What is insider trading? Is it a major problem?
- Should tax evasion carry the same sentences as theft?
- Do you think governments do enough to prosecute money laundering?
- Should companies be given criminal records, not just fines?
- Is it ethical for a law firm to defend a company it knows is guilty of fraud?
- What is the impact of corruption on developing countries?
- Should executives of banks that cause financial crises face criminal charges?
Restorative justice
- What is restorative justice? How does it differ from traditional punishment?
- Do you think meeting your offender would help a victim heal?
- Are there cases where restorative justice is not appropriate?
- Can restorative justice work for serious crimes like assault?
- What evidence is there that restorative justice reduces reoffending?
- Should restorative justice programmes be expanded in your country?
- How do communities benefit from restorative justice approaches?
- Is it fair to ask victims to participate in restorative justice?
- Can businesses use restorative justice principles internally?
- Would you be willing to participate in a restorative justice process if you were a victim?
Mixed B2 questions
- What is the statute of limitations? Do you think it is fair?
- Should the age of criminal responsibility be raised or lowered?
- How should the justice system deal with criminals who have mental illness?
- Is incarceration of mothers with young children always justified?
- Should criminals be allowed to profit from selling their stories to the media?
- Do you think anonymous tip lines are effective in reducing crime?
- Should people convicted of minor crimes have their records automatically expunged after a period of time?
- Is it fair that some crimes carry mandatory minimum sentences regardless of circumstances?
- What do you think of plea bargaining as a practice?
- Should jurors be allowed to know a defendant’s criminal history?
C1–C2 Advanced Questions on Crime and Justice (100 Questions)
These questions are designed for advanced and proficiency-level learners. They explore the philosophy of law, criminal psychology, international justice, moral complexity, and the future of crime and punishment.
Philosophy of law and justice
- What is the difference between law and morality?
- Is it ever morally right to break the law?
- Should the law reflect public opinion, or should it lead public opinion?
- What is natural law theory, and do you think it holds merit?
- Can a legal act be morally wrong? Give examples.
- What is the purpose of punishment in a just society?
- Is retributive justice fundamentally different from restorative justice in its assumptions about human nature?
- To what extent should criminal intent be the defining factor in determining guilt?
- Is ignorance of the law a valid defence?
- Can a society have genuine justice without equality?
Criminal psychology
- What motivates serial offenders to continue committing crimes despite consequences?
- To what extent is psychopathy a mitigating factor in criminal sentencing?
- Can early childhood intervention effectively reduce the likelihood of criminal behaviour?
- How reliable is eyewitness testimony? Should it be weighted differently in court?
- What role does impulse control play in criminal behaviour?
- Is there a meaningful distinction between evil and mental illness in the context of crime?
- How do trauma and adverse childhood experiences contribute to adult criminal behaviour?
- Should neuroscience findings about the criminal brain be used to inform sentencing?
- What is the psychology behind radicalisaion into extremist groups?
- Can someone who commits a terrible act still be considered a good person overall?
International law and global justice
- What is the International Criminal Court and how effective is it?
- Should powerful nations be held to the same standards of international law as smaller ones?
- Is the United Nations effective in enforcing international justice?
- How should the international community respond to genocide?
- What is the principle of universal jurisdiction?
- Should former heads of state enjoy immunity from prosecution?
- How should war crimes be prosecuted?
- Is transitional justice in post-conflict societies effective?
- What is the tension between national sovereignty and international human rights law?
- Should richer nations bear more responsibility for global environmental crimes?
Ethics of punishment
- Is punishment that does not rehabilitate morally justifiable?
- Can incarceration ever be truly rehabilitative given current prison conditions in most countries?
- Should the primary goal of sentencing be public protection, rehabilitation, or retribution?
- Is collective punishment ever acceptable?
- How should the justice system balance the rights of the accused with the rights of victims?
- Is solitary confinement a form of torture?
- What ethical issues arise from the privatisation of prisons?
- Should people who have served their sentences be considered to have paid their debt to society fully?
- Is there a right to a second chance for all offenders, regardless of the severity of their crime?
- Can mandatory sentencing ever be compatible with justice?
Future of crime and justice
- How will artificial intelligence change policing and crime prevention?
- Could predictive policing lead to discrimination against certain groups?
- Will cybercrime eventually outpace the ability of law enforcement to respond?
- How should the law adapt to crimes committed by autonomous AI systems?
- Should virtual crimes in the metaverse be prosecuted as real crimes?
- Will genetic profiling become a standard tool in criminal investigations?
- How might climate change contribute to rising crime rates globally?
- Could a universal basic income reduce property crime significantly?
- Will prisons eventually be replaced by electronic monitoring systems?
- What would a truly just criminal justice system look like in 2050?
Race, identity, and justice
- Is systemic racism embedded in the criminal justice system? How?
- How does implicit bias affect the decisions of police officers and judges?
- Should diversity and unconscious bias training be mandatory for all legal professionals?
- Do stop-and-search powers disproportionately target minority communities?
- What reforms are needed to make the justice system more equitable?
- Is the over-representation of certain groups in prison a justice issue or a social one?
- How does colonialism continue to affect criminal justice systems in formerly colonised nations?
- Should indigenous communities have their own parallel justice systems?
- How does intersectionality affect criminal justice outcomes?
- What role do community organisations play in addressing racial injustice within the legal system?
Controversial and debatable positions
- Is the entire concept of punishment outdated? Should it be replaced entirely by rehabilitation?
- Should criminal records be abolished for all but the most serious offences?
- Are prisons fundamentally institutions of social control rather than justice?
- Should there be a statute of limitations on all crimes, including murder?
- Is it ever ethical to use illegally obtained evidence in court?
- Should jurors be allowed to judge the law itself, not just the facts (jury nullification)?
- Can anonymous witness testimony be compatible with the right to a fair trial?
- Should habitual offenders face indefinite detention?
- Is life imprisonment ever more cruel than the death penalty?
- Is it ever justified for a government to use extrajudicial measures against criminals?
Mixed C1–C2 questions
- What is the relationship between democracy and the rule of law?
- Can a state be considered legitimate if its laws are fundamentally unjust?
- How should societies deal with the crimes of authoritarian regimes after democratisation?
- What is the legal and moral significance of the Nuremberg trials?
- Should companies that knowingly cause public health crises (e.g., tobacco, opioids) face criminal charges?
- How does the revolving door between corporate lobbying and government regulators create conditions for crime?
- To what extent do economic systems themselves generate conditions for crime?
- How does the concept of honour affect crime and justice in different cultures?
- Can the concept of criminal intent be meaningfully applied to corporations?
- Should amnesty ever be offered to combatants in a civil war as part of a peace deal?
Final advanced questions
- Is the overcriminalisation of poverty a form of structural violence?
- How should the justice system balance proportionality with the need for deterrence?
- What is the philosophical basis for the presumption of innocence?
- To what extent is crime a social construct rather than an objective category?
- How does the concept of moral luck apply to criminal responsibility?
- Should people be held criminally responsible for acts of omission as well as acts of commission?
- Is there a tension between restorative justice values and demands for accountability?
- What does justice mean to you personally, and does the formal justice system deliver it?
- Can a society that tolerates extreme wealth inequality ever claim to have a just legal system?
- If you could redesign the criminal justice system from scratch, what three principles would guide it?
Crime and Justice Vocabulary for ESL Students
Before using these questions in class, pre-teach key vocabulary to ensure your students can discuss the topic confidently. Here are the most important words and phrases, organised by level.
Essential vocabulary (A2–B1)
| Word | Definition | Example sentence |
|---|---|---|
| crime | An act that is against the law | Theft is a crime in every country. |
| criminal | A person who commits a crime | The criminal was caught by the police. |
| arrest | When police take someone into custody | The suspect was arrested near the scene. |
| trial | A legal process to decide if someone is guilty | The trial lasted three weeks. |
| guilty | Responsible for a crime | The jury found him guilty. |
| innocent | Not responsible for a crime | She was proven innocent. |
| sentence | The punishment given by a court | He received a five-year sentence. |
| prison / jail | A place where criminals are held | She was sent to prison for fraud. |
| victim | A person who suffers from a crime | The victim reported the theft immediately. |
| witness | A person who sees a crime or gives evidence | The witness described the attacker. |
| fine | Money paid as a punishment | He received a £200 fine for speeding. |
| evidence | Information used in a trial | The fingerprints were strong evidence. |
Advanced vocabulary (B2–C2)
| Word | Definition | Example sentence |
|---|---|---|
| acquit | To find someone not guilty in court | The defendant was acquitted of all charges. |
| bail | Money paid to release a suspect before trial | He was released on bail. |
| parole | Early release from prison under conditions | She was granted parole after two years. |
| prosecute | To take legal action against someone | The company was prosecuted for fraud. |
| conviction | A verdict of guilty | His conviction was overturned on appeal. |
| deterrent | Something that discourages criminal behaviour | Heavy fines act as a deterrent. |
| rehabilitation | Helping a criminal return to a normal life | Rehabilitation reduces reoffending rates. |
| incarceration | The state of being imprisoned | Mass incarceration is a major policy issue. |
| defendant | The person accused in a court case | The defendant denied all charges. |
| jurisdiction | The authority of a legal body in a given area | This crime falls outside our jurisdiction. |
| verdict | The decision of a jury or judge | The jury delivered a not-guilty verdict. |
| extradition | Sending a suspect to another country for trial | The extradition request was approved. |
| plea bargain | An agreement to plead guilty for a reduced sentence | He accepted a plea bargain. |
| vigilante | A person who takes the law into their own hands | Vigilante justice can lead to abuse. |
| reoffend | To commit a crime again after being punished | Many prisoners reoffend within a year of release. |
Teacher Tips: How to Use These Crime and Justice Questions
1. Warm up the topic sensitively
Crime can be a sensitive topic — some students may have personal experiences with crime, victimisation, or the justice system. Before diving in, use a low-stakes warm-up such as asking students to name a crime TV show they enjoy or to rate how safe they feel in their city on a scale of 1 to 10. This eases students into the theme without putting anyone on the spot.
2. Match questions to controversy level
Not all questions carry the same emotional weight. Group the questions roughly into three tiers before your lesson: low controversy (safety, rules, TV shows), medium controversy (punishment, police), and high controversy (death penalty, systemic racism, terrorism). Start with the lower tier and build up as students become more comfortable and engaged.
3. Use pair work before whole-class discussion
Give students time to discuss two or three questions in pairs before opening the conversation to the whole class. This gives quieter students time to formulate their ideas, build confidence in their vocabulary, and reduce the anxiety of speaking in front of the group. Pairs can then share a summary of their discussion with the class.
4. Pre-teach vocabulary before the lesson
Use the vocabulary tables above to pre-teach key terms at the start of your lesson. A quick matching activity (word + definition) or a short gap-fill exercise using the example sentences takes just ten minutes and ensures students have the tools they need to discuss the topic without getting stuck.
5. Suggested follow-up tasks
- Debate: Use questions from the debate-ready sections (death penalty, drug legalisation, systemic inequality) as prompts for a formal or informal debate.
- Role-play: Ask students to role-play a courtroom scene — judge, defendant, prosecutor, and witness — using vocabulary from the tables above.
- Writing: Assign a short opinion essay using one of the advanced questions as a prompt.
- Research task: Ask students to find a famous crime case from their country and present it to the class.
- Discussion cards: Print selected questions on cards and use them as a speaking activity with a timer.
6. Handle sensitive moments with care
If a student shares a personal experience related to crime, treat it with respect, acknowledge their contribution, and gently steer the conversation to keep everyone comfortable. It is always okay to skip a question that feels too sensitive for a particular group. You know your students best — trust your instincts.
Final Thoughts
Crime and justice is one of those rare ESL topics that works at every level, in almost every context. Beginners can talk about safety and rules; advanced learners can debate the philosophy of punishment and the future of the justice system. The questions above give you everything you need to fill a lesson — or a whole unit — with genuine, opinion-driven English practice.
If you found this resource helpful, explore more of our conversation question collections below. You might also enjoy our ESL debate topics, our collection of role-play scenarios, and our guide to the best ESL warm-up activities to start any lesson with energy.
Discover more from ESL Info
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

